Saturday, October 23, 2010

Gluten-free Pancake Mixes, A Blind Taste Test


It is pancake breakfast season in the San Francisco schools. I don't live there, but I get announcements for these, and have been surprised as how many of these breakfasts offer gluten free pancakes. There are so many pancake options out there, which pleases my pancake loving kids. The mixes are easy to make in small portions, it would be nice if more restaurants would offer them too. It would certainly please the sweet breakfast loving crowd. Not sure which mix to try? Well, read on and get the results of a blind taste test.



We convened a panel of 18 tasters: Eight adults and ten kids, ranging from 3-8 years old. Tasters were given bite sized plain samples identified only by letter and asked to rate the pancakes and provide comments. Small kids rated the pancakes on a happy face scale. After samples, tasters got to make their own custom pancakes with mix-ins and toppings... My kids I think got enough sugar in their 2 massive pancakes to power them for weeks!

Overall tasters were surprised on how un-opinionated they were about the samples. Most found flaws in each and things they enjoyed about each, but did not feel like there huge differences. Artfully topped, most mixes passed muster. In fact, all mixes except three received both high and low ratings. Only one received all high ratings - Bisquick.



Arrowhead Mills: This received middle of the road ratings, with some noting that it was dry. In fact, the provided recipe created a batter that was too thick to cook, so we had to loosen it up. However, no off flavors were detected.

Bisquick: This newcomer received the highest ratings overall and was the only mix that did not receive any low ratings. Tasters appreciated the fluffy texture that reminded them of "real" pancakes.


Bob's Red Mill: This mix was rated in the middle of the road, with some liking the buttermilky flavor and others disliking the strong flavor.

Cherrybrook Kitchen: This vegan, allergen free mix was the overall winner for some, yet poorly rated by others. It is a very sweet, vanilla scented mix that reminded some people of eating "cake." The resulting pancakes are substantial and with chew - again loved by some and less so by others.

Gluten-free Pantry: Another mix rated in the middle of the road. Some found the resulting pancake a bit dry, but found the flavor pleasant.

King Arthur Flour: This newcomer was rated well, with tasters highlighting the fluffy texture of the pancakes. A few tasters felt that the pancakes needed more flavor.

Pamela's: coming into the tasting this was many tasters declared favorite. Indeed it fared well, but was not the highest rated. Tasters enjoyed the taste of this mix, with it's buttermilk studded batter, but felt the texture was not as fluffy as other mixes.

Simply Organic: This mix was the only mix made with some whole grains and the recipe did not call for any additional fat beyond the egg. However, tasters felt that the whole grain taste was too strong, and the pancakes were far too dry. 

Trader Joe's: This mix, purportedly made by Namaste, received all around low ratings. Tasters detected a strong off flavor and did not appreciate the texture of the pancakes.

Homemade: This mix is a work in progress. I slipped it in to get some honest feedback. Many tasters rated this highly for its taste, but the texture needed work. I reworked the recipe after the tasting and it is below. It results in a very moist pancake with a rich flavor. Aaron said he really liked the flavor, but it was still too "chewy" while Isaiah liked the texture. If you want less chew, just swap out some tapioca for some rice flour or my favorite buckwheat flour.



Recipe

Homemade rich moist gluten-free pancake mix

This mix is buttery, milky and has a slight malt flavor from the molasses. Just store the mix in your refrigerator or freezer and to make it up add 1 egg and about 1 cup buttermilk to each 1 1/2 cup of mix.

3/4 cup buckwheat*
1 3/4 cup brown rice flour
1/2 cup cornstarch
1 cup tapioca starch
1 3/4 cup white rice flour
1 3/4 cup potato starch
1 3/4 cup powdered milk
2 T + 2 t baking powder
1 t baking soda
4 t salt
1 T molasses
1/2 cup sugar
 12 T cold butter but into 1/2 inch pieces

Put all ingredients in a food processor and blend well. If your food processor is not big enough, blend the dry ingredients in a bowl with the whisk. Then put a few cups of the flour with the rest of the ingredients in a food processor. Blend well, and then whisk into the rest of the flour.

7 comments:

  1. Wow! What a great post. Been following along for a while now... but this is one of my favorites! Thank you for sharing your experiment. I actually linked to it on my Facebook page. (Celiac in the City)

    I have Bisquick in the cupboard that I haven't tried yet. Time to get it out!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Great Post! Try using two eggs at room temperature. Separate the eggs and whites, add the yolks to your batter, and then whip the egg whites and fold them in just before making the pancakes. It will greatly improve the texture of your pancakes. Heck, yours will probably beat the competition! Also, have you ever tried using canola or vegetable oil instead of butter? It makes a lighter/fluffier pancake as well.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Nancy - I have used the egg separation trick before. The goal here was a super quick mix I can have my 6 year old whip up, but I agree that folding in whipped egg whites really is nice. I prefer the taste of butter - my heart isn't happy about it but what can I say : ). We were trying to imitate traditional bisquick, which has the fat already added. My kids can just crack and egg and add buttermilk, water or milk and be done with it.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I noted that you did not mention CeliMix.

    Is this because this is a Canadian brand and not available to you?

    To me - this mix comes quite close to what I remember as wheat pancakes although perhaps a bit more firm.

    Made by Nelson David of Canada Ltd. Winnipeg, Manitoba.

    CelliMix Brnad - Light and Fluffy Pancake Mix.

    I'm hoping for some this morning!

    ReplyDelete
  5. After showing this to my husband - he said this should be printed in Living Without magazine.

    Here's the link - http://www.livingwithout.com/contact/

    ReplyDelete
  6. hi -- i have tried many of these -- my favorite for a LONG time was Kinnikinnick (sp?) but lately it's been either Bisquick!

    The Kinnik brand has a great sweet flavor, but they are not very fluffy at all -- the bisquick is GREAT! oh -- better batter's pancake mix is also really good!

    ReplyDelete
  7. 5 Tips to a flat stomach
    ----------------------------------
    Stop making these 5 Major mistakes and you will finally lose your stubborn belly fat
    There are long lasting ways to get the amazing middle you crave. These genius tips
    Will help you shed inches and pounds, banish the bloat, And feel even more gorgeous.
    we have very best advice for quickly shrinking your tummy. Here are the surprising
    Hello, skinny jeans!
    http://juicyabs.com
    http://www.facebook.com/5TipsToAFlatStomach?skip_nax_wizard=true

    ReplyDelete